Every week, SPIN digs into the catalogs of nice artists and highlights songs you may not know for our Deep Reduce Friday collection.
The duality of enjoyment and ache, of comedy and tragedy, or of life’s highs and lows is fertile territory for songwriters. And John Mellencamp has created some nice songs out of these and related themes, together with “Hurts So Good,” “Down and Out in Paradise,” “Unhappy Clowns,” and particularly “Between a Giggle and a Tear” from 1985’s Scarecrow. Rickie Lee Jones’s backing vocals add one thing particular to Mellencamp’s wry, bittersweet lyrics, however they didn’t document collectively in particular person. Apparently, Mellencamp was such a fan that he was nervous to satisfy Jones in particular person, and opted to have her document in Los Angeles moderately than fly her out to his newly constructed Belmont Mall Studio in Indiana.
In fact, Mellencamp was a reasonably large star in his personal proper by 1985, and Scarecrow was his third large multi-platinum hit. It was additionally the album that lastly gained over rock critics who’d been lukewarm on the heartland rocker, touchdown him on the Village Voice’s Pazz & Jop critics’ ballot for the primary time—in third place proper behind extra established important darlings Speaking Heads and the Replacements. Seven completely different songs from Scarecrow charted on rock radio, however “Between a Giggle and a Tear” wasn’t certainly one of them. A 2022 reissue of Scarecrow featured a short demo of the track that doesn’t have all of the phrases, however options a wonderful rendering of the track’s vocal melody in a barely completely different tempo.
Mellencamp hasn’t performed “Between a Giggle and a Tear” a lot on tour since 1986. However he revisited it for 1999’s Tough Harvest, which was recorded reside within the studio by Mellencamp and his band, as soon as once more in Belmont Mall. The gathering of covers and new preparations of outdated Mellencamp favorites, principally widespread singles, fulfilled his contractual obligations to Mercury Information earlier than he signed a brand new cope with Columbia. “Between a Giggle and a Tear” stands out as one of many lesser recognized tracks on Tough Harvest, and in addition one of many extra dramatic reinventions, hauntingly quiet and a full 90 seconds shorter than the Scarecrow model.
Three extra important John Mellencamp deep album cuts:
“Low-cost Shot”
Mellencamp was generally known as Johnny Cougar or John Cougar on his first six albums, lastly dropping the Cougar in 1991. His 1980 album Nothin’ Issues and What If It Did, nonetheless, ends with Mellencamp thumbing his nostril on the man who found and renamed him, Tony DeFries: “Properly, the document firm’s changin’ my title now / Properly, the document firm’s goin’ out of enterprise!”
“Jackie O”
After I interviewed Mellencamp a couple of years in the past, I requested about his friendship with the late nice John Prine, and he was self-deprecating about their collaborations: “He would come to Indiana and we’d sit round and write stuff, however we by no means wrote something superb, to be fairly sincere.” The 2 songs they wrote collectively that did get launched are gems, although: Mellencamp’s playful 1983 track “Jackie O” and Prine’s wistful 1995 observe “Take a Have a look at My Coronary heart.”
“Brothers”
One among Mellencamp’s two brothers, the late Ted Mellencamp, was his tour supervisor. It’s not clear if the darkish story of sibling rivalry that he tells in “Brothers” is in any manner autobiographical, the track contains a number of the most compelling lyrics on 1994’s Dance Bare.
