Early in his profession, John Mellencamp had a alternative. He might both change his identify and launch his first album on MCA Data, or he might head again house to Seymour, Ind. Potential rock stardom or a minimal wage job for the telephone firm – these have been the choices for the younger singer, not even 25 years previous, when offered with the stage identify of Johnny Cougar.
“Nobody’s ever referred to as me Johnny in my life,” Mellencamp complained, maybe not understanding how you can start to handle Cougar. He had been making an attempt to achieve consideration from the music business for a pair years, making routine journeys to New York Metropolis from the Midwest, and had little luck. That’s, till Tony DeFries heard his demo tape.
DeFries ran MainMan administration, and his purchasers included David Bowie, Lou Reed and Iggy Pop. DeFries appreciated Mellencamp’s voice. He appreciated his James Dean look much more. What he didn’t look after was his unusual German final identify. The supervisor was satisfied that nobody was going to purchase a document from a singer named Mellencamp.
“We wished one thing uniquely American, one thing sizzling and wild,” MainMan affiliate Jamie Andrews instructed Seventeen journal. “Johnny Indiana was one among our selections, Puma, Mustang – however nothing was as sizzling as Cougar!”
Learn Extra: Why John Mellencamp Advised Some Followers to ‘Shut the Fuck Up’
Mellencamp didn’t agree, however he went together with it to get his debut album launched. “I might have signed something – I might have signed the underside of a shoe,” Mellencamp instructed Rolling Stone in 2013.
Within the quick time period, the deal didn’t look so nice for “Johnny Cougar.” When his debut album, 1976’s Chestnut Avenue Incident, moved solely 12,000 copies and he was excoriated within the press as a slight Bruce Springsteen substitute, Mellencamp’s second LP, The Child Inside, was shelved by MainMan. He quickly was dropped by MCA.
Hearken to Johnny Cougar’s ‘Chestnut Avenue’
Although Mellencamp would admit the album wasn’t nice, he blamed Johnny Cougar’s preliminary flame-out on DeFries and his rampant over-hyping of his new consumer. Even though Mellencamp had solely begun to write down songs, DeFries was evaluating him to one of many greats: “He’s so American, probably the most American artist I’ve seen since Bob Dylan, and I believe he’ll seize the identical form of factor Dylan did.”
After MCA walked away, so did MainMan, leaving Mellencamp with a flop, an unreleased album and a “fairly foolish” identify.
However moderately than ditching the moniker, Mellencamp would alter it to easily John Cougar; he had at all times bristled on the concept of being “Johnny” something. He wanted a reputation that wouldn’t drive him loopy.
“I used to be washed up and over by my mid-twenties,” he mentioned. “However I knew if I delivered a track that would get on the radio, I had a shot.”
He signed with new administration and made a document in England. A Biography didn’t see launch within the States, however scored an unlikely hit in Australia with “I Want a Lover.” Success, even down underneath, breeds alternative, and the newly christened John Cougar obtained one other shot at American rock stardom. “I Want a Lover” was added to his subsequent U.S. album (titled John Cougar) and commenced a modest U.S. single for the singer, in addition to a radio hit for Pat Benatar.
Watch John Cougar Carry out ‘I Want a Lover’ on ‘American Bandstand’ in 1979
“There have been at all times managers wanting to place their two cents in,” Mellencamp mirrored in 2005. “However after that Johnny Cougar debacle, I just about rejected about all the things they ever mentioned.”
Nonetheless, Mellencamp would stay John Cougar by means of his 1982 breakthrough, American Idiot, with its smash hits “Hurts So Good” and “Jack & Diane.” Having the No. 1 single and album on the Billboard charts (Mellencamp’s first and solely chart-toppers) was each a blessing and a curse. As John Cougar, Mellencamp had fame, fortune and a Grammy, however he nonetheless wasn’t himself, actually.
Plus, DeFries determined to re-enter the Johnny Cougar market after American Idiot. In 1983, he opened the vault and at last put out The Child Inside, in a bid for money from new Cougar followers hungry for extra music. It will be the final album of Mellencamp’s profession to not function his actual final identify.
Being an MTV and radio star helped the singer-songwriter achieve some extra inventive management, which confirmed within the sly songcraft and rougher sound of his subsequent album, 1983’s Uh-Huh. It was additionally borne out on the LP’s cowl, which featured the “new” identify of John Cougar Mellencamp. In distinction to DeFries’ authentic judgment, it seems lots of people would purchase information from a man named Mellencamp. Uh-Huh went multi-platinum, delivering three High 20 Billboard hits – “Pink Homes,” “Authority Music” and “Crumblin’ Down” – that stay a few of his most well-known songs.
Watch the Video for John Cougar Mellencamp’s ‘Authority Music’
If Mellencamp couldn’t outrun the “Cougar” simply but, he might document the form of music he cherished. By means of the remainder of the ’80s, John Cougar Mellencamp would write each deeply private and political songs, add rustic touches of fiddle and accordion to his sound and proceed to have hit singles and albums. Scarecrow, The Lonesome Jubilee and Huge Daddy all went platinum (or higher) whereas “Lonely Ol’ Evening,” “Small City,” ���R.O.C.Okay. in the united statesA.,” “Paper in Fireplace” and “Cherry Bomb” all hit the High 10.
With a streak of success, each industrial and important, Mellencamp lastly reclaimed his identify. When 1991’s Each time We Needed hit document retailer cabinets, it bore the precise identify of the person who made it: John Mellencamp.
The prolific musician been recording as himself, ever since. As John Mellencamp, he’s turn into one among rock’s elder statesmen, persevering with to place out new music, tour the world and promote American farmers – in addition to salve his passions within the visible arts. He’s been honored by ASCAP and the Americana Music Affiliation, and he’s been inducted into the Rock and Roll Corridor of Fame. Johnny Money even referred to as him one among music’s 10 greatest songwriters. Fairly excessive reward for a musician who’s seen as quintessentially American.
So if Tony DeFries wasn’t proper that Johnny Cougar was “probably the most American artist [he had] seen,” he was nearly on the cash when it got here to John Mellencamp.
Rock’s Most Overshadowed Debuts
From David Bowie’s missed first album to Dave Grohl’s pre-Nirvana document with Scream.
Gallery Credit score: UCR Workers
Odd {Couples}: John Mellencamp and Mick Ronson
