Prue’s Death in ‘Charmed’ Always Made Perfect Sense

Charmed, which aired from 1998 to 2006, noticed three sisters band collectively to cease evil threats — demons, the Supply of All Evil, and the like — as essentially the most highly effective good witches the world had ever seen: The Charmed Ones. These sisters had been, initially, Prue (Shannen Doherty), Piper (Holly Marie Combs), and Phoebe (Alyssa Milano), three girls who had spent their lives in San Francisco and had been now tasked with stopping the town from being destroyed on a weekly foundation. However, shortly after the third season completed, Doherty exited the present and Prue was subsequently killed off after Prue and Piper had been left for lifeless by the Supply’s murderer, Shax (Michael Bailey Smith), within the Season 3 finale.

As a result of behind-the-scenes points presumably liable for Doherty’s exit (of which there are lots of rumors which have been circulating for over twenty years), many have speculated what the present would have been like if Prue had survived and one of many different sisters died — specifically Phoebe — and left house for Paige (Rose McGowan) to affix the household of their stead. Nonetheless, whether or not or not it was deliberate beforehand, Prue’s dying all the time made excellent sense and tragically introduced actual stakes to the Halliwells’ lives as witches in a manner that the deaths of their mom Patty (Finola Hughes) and grandmother Penny (Jennifer Rhodes) by no means may.

Charmed (1998)

Three Halliwell sisters uncover that they’re descendants of a line of fine feminine witches and are destined to struggle in opposition to the forces of evil, utilizing their mixed energy of witchcraft often known as the “Energy of Three.”

Launch Date

October 7, 1998

Essential Style

Supernatural

Seasons

8

Variety of Episodes

178

Prue Had a Life That Adopted Her Mom’s in ‘Charmed’

All through her whole life, Prue subconsciously tried to separate herself from her mom as a lot as attainable. The considered ending up like her mother terrified her, and she or he felt it an inevitability. Seems, Prue was proper, which made her finish much more tragic than it might’ve already been. Destiny places Prue in comparable sneakers to her mom, as Prue even factors out these similarities within the episode “P3 H20” from Season 2 as they face the demon that killed Patty — no profitable relationship, liable for a household, and the very actual risk of dying younger due to being a Charmed One. Because the oldest sister, and unarguably essentially the most highly effective of the three, Prue typically takes the lead and stands as much as shield Piper and Phoebe from no matter evil they’re going through. She’s the one persistently in entrance along with her sisters on both sides of her, able to take the brunt of an enemy’s assault. That is even true when going through the demon that killed their mom, as Prue’s telekinetic powers are the important thing and she or he’s the one confronted with going out on the dock within the lake to slay the monster.

Even with Prue conscious of the similarities between her mom and herself, nothing actually modified. She couldn’t discover a profitable relationship with a person, simply temporary flings like with Jack (Lochlyn Munro), and nothing would have taken Prue away from being the top of the household. The load of that was by no means going away, no matter the truth that Piper’s membership started to present them the cash to pay their payments.

After Prue’s dying, Piper and Phoebe perceive the severity and price of being a witch excess of earlier than. Piper’s greatest concern, up till Prue’s dying, had been that her witchly duties would make having a standard life unattainable. Phoebe, however, completely adored being a witch and thought it was enjoyable — like we see from Paige and Billie (Kaley Cuoco) later within the collection earlier than they expertise the associated fee and loss that comes with their powers. Shedding their mom to a demon did emphasize how harmful it could possibly be, nevertheless it occurred when the women had been so younger that Prue was actually the one one to know how excessive the stakes had been from the very starting. Shedding Patty hardened Prue and made her the household’s protector, which their grandmother all the time impressed upon them rising up. In the end, a lot of Prue’s story added as much as her tragically dying younger.

Associated

The Finest Visitor Star of ‘Charmed’ Was in Its First Season

This tragic character set an ordinary within the present’s first season.

Prue’s Loss of life In the end Made ‘Charmed’ Higher

Most notably is the episode “Loss of life Takes A Halliwell” from the third season, the place Prue encounters the Angel of Loss of life and makes an attempt to struggle him off as he tries to say two innocents’ souls. The lesson of this episode, for Prue, is that dying isn’t the enemy, and she or he can’t cease dying from occurring regardless of how onerous she fights. It’s one thing she’s been combating since dropping her mom, and one thing she’s remained fearful of, with that concern solely highlighted by the deaths of her longtime lover Andy (T.W. King) and their grandmother. However, because the episode aired shortly earlier than Prue died, it additionally serves as a warning for Prue to not struggle dying normally. Loss of life teases that it’s not Prue’s time but, and if Prue didn’t have this premature encounter, she could have fought dying (whereas lifeless) and never discovered peace along with her family members within the afterlife, as viewers had seen others do all through the present.

There isn’t any doubt that Prue would have somewhat died herself as a substitute of one in every of her sisters, and it wouldn’t actually have labored if one in every of her sisters had died. Prue wouldn’t have been capable of proceed on if she misplaced Piper and/or Phoebe. She was virtually their mom for all intents and functions, and spent a lot of her life looking for them and ensuring they had been all the time taken care of. That was, basically, her objective on the earth, and she or he felt the strain of that till her dying day. And, after dropping one in every of her sisters, it appears inconceivable that Prue would have been capable of open up to and let Paige into her world. The guilt would have eaten Prue alive, and she or he doubtless wouldn’t have been capable of carry out her Wiccan duties and preserve the world secure. Prue had already felt the load of loss so totally all through her life, excess of her sisters as a consequence of being the eldest, and it might have pushed her over the sting. Even after Andy died, Prue thought-about giving all of it up due to that loss within the Season 2 premiere when Abraxas threatened to remove their powers altogether.

In the long run, Prue’s story ended precisely how the writers had all the time made it appear it might: Her dying. Whereas it’s unhappy (and that is coming from somebody whose favourite character on Charmed is and all the time has been Prue), it’s additionally tragically stunning. Viewers may suggest that Prue reunited along with her mom and long-lost love within the afterlife, content material to look at her sisters stay lengthy, comfortable lives due to her sacrifice. Prue’s dying gave Piper the energy to step up and an instance of the right way to lead the household, and the opposite two sisters had been all the time more likely to just accept Paige than Prue. Deliberate or not, the Charmed writers advised an sudden, devastating, and unbelievable story with Prue. Whereas it might’ve been nice to see her get a fortunately ever after whereas alive, the ending match the character extremely properly.

All eight seasons of Charmed are streaming on Prime Video.

Watch on Prime Video