Streaming at residence stays the favorite leisure exercise throughout generations. To cater to this demand, unimaginable content material is being produced and streamed on OTT Platforms and this has led to a raging debate throughout the globe on content material censorship within the OTT area.
India has been within the centre of this debate. The regulation of this area will shift the sands of the media and leisure panorama.
With Covid restrictions, theatrical releases have been restricted and this led to conventional manufacturing homes turning to OTT platforms. The comfort an OTT platform supplies to its viewers has led to an exponential improve within the time spent by people viewing streaming content material on-line. It’s only pure due to this fact that the eye of lawmakers has turned to OTT platforms.
In contrast to tv broadcasting in India, which is ruled beneath The Cable Networks Tv (Regulation) Act, 1995, and the exhibition of films, which is regulated by the Cinematograph Act, 1952, which supplies for certification of films earlier than they are often exhibited, on-line content material will not be certain by any particular provision governing the provision of content material on an OTT platform. Nonetheless, such content material is topic to sure current legal guidelines and guidelines, reminiscent of:
Indian Penal Code, 1860: Any one that indulges within the actions of promoting and distributing any work of literature which is obscene will be punished beneath Part 293, so can an individual who has the intention of outraging spiritual sentiments with malice beneath Part 295A. Releasing defamatory content material is punishable beneath Part 499 and when an individual insults the modesty of a girl, he’s responsible for punishment beneath Part 354.
Indecent Illustration of Girls (Prevention) Act, 1986: This legislation explicitly prohibits the indecent illustration of girls in ads, motion pictures, books and on-line content material.
Data Know-how Act, 2000: Publishing or transmitting materials containing sexually specific acts, and so on., in digital kind is punishable beneath Part 67A. Publishing or transmitting materials depicting youngsters in sexually specific acts, and so on., in digital kind is punishable beneath Part 67B. The Authorities beneath Part 69A has the ability to dam public entry to such materials.
Safety of Youngsters from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act: Its provisions will be invoked to guard youngsters from each on-line and offline offences. This is among the key items of laws that ensures the safety of youngsters from numerous offences, together with on-line harassment and internet pornography.
Article 19(1) of the Structure ensures the liberty of speech and expression to all, however this proper is topic to restrictions spelt out in Article 19(2) within the pursuits of the sovereignty and integrity of the nation, the safety of the State, pleasant relations with overseas states, public order, decency or morality, and in relation to contempt of court docket, defamation or incitement to an offence.
As provisions of the Cinematograph Act, 1952, are relevant to movies meant for launch in theatres and to not those which are transmitted by way of the medium of the Web, any certifications of a movie by the CBFC doesn’t apply to content material streamed on OTT platforms.
These platforms, in consequence, have loved full freedom not like conventional cinema and this has led to quite a few situations the place complaints have been filed on the grounds of obscenity, hurting spiritual sentiments, little one pornography, so on and so forth, therefore the to manage this area.
This was additionally noticed by the Supreme Courtroom whereas listening to a plea filed by Amazon. “Conventional movie viewing has develop into out of date,” the honourable court docket opined. “Individuals watching movies on these platforms has develop into frequent. Ought to there not be some screening? We really feel there needs to be some screening… At instances they’re displaying pornography too.”
The court docket acknowledged {that a} sure diploma of screening of content material was obligatory earlier than movies or internet collection are streamed into the properties of the general public at massive.
To handle this matter, the Ministry of Data and Broadcasting consulted a number of stakeholders on types of regulation of OTT platforms to make the sector extra environment friendly. On the finish of those consultations, the Authorities issued the Data Know-how (Tips for Intermediaries and Digital Media Ethics Code) Guidelines, 2021 (‘IT Guidelines’), which lays down the next tips for the intermediaries, together with OTT platforms, to observe beneath Data Know-how Act:
(a) OTT platforms are required to self-categorise content material into 5 age-based classes: U (Common), U/A-7, U/A-13, U/A-16 and A (Grownup).
(b) A parental lock must be offered by OTT platforms.
(c) Digital media will even must observe the Norms of Journalistic Conduct of the Press Council of India and the Programme Code beneath the Cable Tv Networks Regulation Act.
(d) They’ve to determine a three-level grievance redressal mechanism, the place the primary degree is self-regulation by OTT platforms; second-level is self-regulation by the self-regulating our bodies of publishers; and the third degree is an oversight mechanism.
(e) It supplies for the appointment of a redressal officer primarily based in India to deal with public grievances inside 15 days.
(f) It requires an extra self-regulatory physique of publishers of no more than six members and a retired decide of the Supreme Courtroom or a Excessive Courtroom, or an eminent particular person.
With OTT platforms turning into collectively one of many largest media markets on the planet, they’re topic to the regulation of the state they exist in. Controlling Web area or OTT platforms will not be a simple process for any authority because the Web area will not be utterly managed by any nation, besides in China and North Korea.
Nations around the globe are within the technique of bringing regulation into the OTT area. Australia, for example, has appointed an eSafety Commissioner for digital media and OTT content material, that are regulated by The Broadcasting Companies Act, 1992. The Act lays down detailed tips, supplies for a grievance mechanism, and has a “refused classification” for prohibited content material.
The rise in streaming content material consumption by the Indian viewers has additionally led to an enormous improve within the variety of OTT platforms launched within the nation to cater to the various sensibilities of the Indian viewers, making India the fastest-growing OTT market on the planet. It has additionally triggered an excessive amount of controversy, with plenty of Indian and overseas exhibits being dragged into disputes over points reminiscent of pornography, defamation and insulting spiritual sentiments, and so forth.
Regardless of the absence of any OTT-specific rules, a slew of instances have been filed towards streaming platforms and this has posed a speedbreaker for OTT platforms. Other than content material removing notices, the platforms have been topic to litigation throughout states.
Lots of the OTT gamers, being of overseas origin, usually are not acquainted with the legal guidelines of the land on issues reminiscent of defamation, hate speech, nationwide safety, cultural insensitivity, political compulsions, and so forth, and the absence of particular laws coping with OTT platforms creates an unfavourable setting.
There’s due to this fact a must put collectively a well-defined complete laws to deal with these points in a method that can present a protected setting for viewers and a degree taking part in discipline for the platforms to flourish and prosper.
(Khushbu Jain is a practising advocate within the Supreme Courtroom and founding associate of the legislation agency Ark Authorized. She will be contacted on Twitter: @advocatekhushbu)
20220403-163805
