Ben’s tragedy in The Umbrella Academy is not simply that he died (twice), it is that he killed himself. The most important thriller in Netflix’s phenomenally profitable present pertains to essentially the most heartbreaking second within the Academy’s lives – the dying of their brother – which was on the root of a lot of the group’s battle. And it is doable that Ben’s story is even darker than it initially appears.
As in Gerard Manner’s authentic Umbrella Academy comedian, Ben’s dying stays a thriller, and the way in which the present offers with the fallout of his dying at a younger age could be very a lot a part of the present’s profitable mannequin of storytelling. The outcomes of the dying – from Ben’s ghostly relationship with Klaus to the way in which his dying modified Sir Reginald’s relationship together with his youngsters in addition to their very own sibling dynamic – are arguably extra vital than the way it occurred. However there are references all through the primary two seasons that appear to consciously search so as to add a form of mystique to these occasions, encouraging followers to debate what occurred.
Crucially, there are additionally hints in The Umbrella Academy season 1 and a couple of that counsel that Ben tragically took his personal life, which modifications all the dynamic of the second and makes Ben’s story much more heartbreaking. It may additionally clarify why Ben is barely ready to make use of his powers after dying by Klaus and likewise why he sticks round as a ghost in any respect.
Ben’s Dying Is A Secret On Objective
Gerard Manner’s Umbrella Academy comics are not any assist to figuring out the key of Ben’s dying. Manner defined to IGN that the reply to Ben’s dying was “past a spoiler” as a result of it hadn’t been explored within the comics and was vital to them, suggesting he clearly has an thought on the way it occurred. Even The Umbrella Academy‘s Netflix show-runner, Steve Blackman has no thought the way it occurred. All that is revealed of what occurred is what Sir Reginald says by means of a eulogy for Ben, as he accuses his younger fees of permitting Quantity Six to die and refuses to listen to any excuses.
It is attention-grabbing to notice the remainder of the Hargreeves’ reactions to the funeral: Allison protests that it wasn’t any of the kids’s fault, Luther appears to really feel guilt saying “Dad was proper, we should always have executed extra, this didn’t need to occur” and Diego takes that as a problem saying he “couldn’t do all of it on my own…you’re purported to be Quantity One!” Clearly, there’s extra to the story than has been revealed and the drip-feed of data is actively designed to make followers speculate. Crucially, if there wasn’t extra purpose to debate the main points of Ben’s dying in The Umbrella Academy, it will have been made explicitly clear what occurred. In actuality, the present needs Ben’s dying to do for the viewers what Sir Reginald says the kids should do: “let it fester in your hearts. So there’s by no means a subsequent time.”
The Lesson Of Ben Hargreeves’ Dying Is Unity
It is attention-grabbing, from that time on that the principle thrust of The Umbrella Academy sees the Hargreeves trying to get again collectively and mend fractured relationships, even after they’re unfold throughout time. Every time one thing threatens to go incorrect it is as a result of one in every of them is remoted or refuses to behave as a part of the staff. 5’s time as an murderer, Viktor’s relationship with Leonard, Diego’s wilful independence in season 2… all of it results in bother. In impact, the lesson they realized from Ben’s dying was to take care of each other and to remain collectively as a household. Even Sir Reginald’s personal suicide was designed to deliver his youngsters again collectively.
Crucially, Viktor’s significance to The Umbrella Academy apocalypse may very well be seen because the “subsequent time” Sir Reginald was warning about. Whereas he performed the tyrant and emotionally abused her to maintain her powers underneath management for the better good, he nonetheless allowed Viktor to be a part of the household. He may have forged him off, however he acknowledged the significance of that help from Viktor’s siblings, which is identical drive that made him make the kids a “mom”. Additionally it is no accident that the apocalypse, in each seasons to this point, has been fended off by the Academy coming collectively. In impact, the Academy could also be flawed, but it surely capabilities greatest for its members when it acts with the identical help mechanisms which are typically lacking for these in despair.
Ben’s Tombstone Explains His Darkish Secret
The key to The Umbrella Academy‘s Ben dying may lie in his gravestone. Regardless of the recommended method of his dying being tragic however heroic on his ultimate mission, Ben’s monument just isn’t one that might be anticipated of such a noble sacrifice. As a substitute, the inscription reads, “Might the darkness inside you discover peace within the gentle”, which clearly has two meanings. The darkness inside pertains to the character of Ben’s powers and his perform as a conduit to a darkish dimension, however in additional typical use, the picture of “darkness inside” suggests emotional turmoil and despair. And “discovering peace” once more displays the concept of somebody outlined by wrestle and battle – precisely the type of eulogy you’ll anticipate of somebody who had taken their very own life, in actual fact.
Ben Killed Himself As a result of Of His Powers
The final remaining query, naturally, is why Ben would kill himself and it may very well be linked to his powers. All of The Umbrella Academy‘s 3 seasons have a operating theme by way of how every of the kids feels about their very own powers, which explains why most of them barely use them. 5 is definitely essentially the most lively, however even he’s reluctant to make use of them, primarily as a result of his lack of management led to him principally ruining his total life. Luther despises the bodily modifications made to his physique, Alison seeks normalcy greater than something, Viktor was actively pressured to suppress his powers, Klaus fears his and Diego chooses to not use his as an expression of his want to show himself to his father. There’s even a touch of Ben’s relationship together with his tentacle powers: through the financial institution theft scene, the others are virtually reveling of their powers, however Ben is reluctant and must be pressured to make use of his.
It may very well be that Ben’s use of his powers got here at a terrific value to him. He was, in any case, turning his physique right into a portal for unspeakable monstrosities. After he is used his powers, he emerges lined in blood, and his nickname within the comics is The Horror. It might be silly to not suppose this could all come at some psychological value. What’s extra, Ben’s powers have been so formidable that it appears unlikely he may have been killed in standard methods; extra probably, he may not stay with being pressured to make use of such nightmarish powers and as a substitute turned them on himself, maybe permitting his physique to be taken again to the dimension the tentacles emerged from. That would even provide an answer to why Ben ages after his dying.
Even his determination to not cross over – which he tells Klaus was his personal alternative and never one thing Klaus pressured him to do – may have been a mirrored image of the style of his dying. Tragically, Ben’s causes for killing himself – not having the ability to deal with household stress and responsibility and the price of his powers – have been eliminated when he died and his ties to his household have been clearer. He took the one probability he had left to remain. In the end, that is all nonetheless vital even past Ben’s second dying, as a result of a brand new Ben is concerned in The Umbrella Academy season 3, so it could be that a solution is lastly definitively supplied.
Ben’s Umbrella Academy Season 3 Sparrow Academy Look Defined
Ben’s tragic dying was all the time theorized to be short-term, and now it is confirmed that not solely is Ben alive in The Umbrella Academy season 3, however he is additionally Quantity One at Reginald Hargreeves’ alternate-timeline Sparrow Academy. The query of how Ben can nonetheless be alive after having died as a baby within the present’s authentic timeline is pretty simple to reply, although; for the reason that different Hargreeves siblings altered the previous with their time within the 60s, the occasions of their current that led to Ben’s dying can simply have been impacted and adjusted. The extra puzzling drawback is why Ben was included in Hargreeves’ new and improved Academy whereas the opposite six Umbrella members weren’t.
There are two predominant theories that specify this. The primary is that Reginald by no means came upon about Ben when he met his different youngsters within the 60s and subsequently had no purpose to be dissatisfied in him and select one other little one for the Sparrow Academy as a substitute. The opposite is that Reginald did know of Ben, however merely could not resist recruiting him a second time due to his powers. Both means, The Umbrella Academy season 3 is bound to supply a bittersweet reunion between Ben and the opposite six siblings.
Need extra Umbrella Academy Articles? Try our important studying under…
About The Writer
